I have a torn ACL. What type of surgery would you suggest in my case?


Question:
I tore my ACL playing soccer about 6 weeks ago. I additionaly have (supposedly) meniscus and bone injuries. I have seen two doctors, and surgery is necessary if i want to play again. I would like to know, which are the pros and cons, of al the options out there: artificial ligament, fram a donor, from my own patella or hamstring tendons, etc. Which recovers better, faster, more effective strength-wise, Less chance of breaking again. I do know my rehab will be tough, but that's not a problems. I've seen tons of soccer players have the same injury, and the recovery (if i want to play at a high level) is long, but that's no problem. Thanks for your help, and opinion

Answers:
The best (in my opinion) is ACL replacement borrowing material from your own knee. Rehab is not easy, but if followed properly you will achieve a full recovery. If you don't have cartilage damage, the pain shouldn't be too bad.
I would suggest full amputation.
i tore my ACL about a year ago playing soccer as well, and i had mine repaired from my own hamstring. i was playing soccer about 6 months after, and my surgery knee was just as strong or even stronger then my other knee. I still wear a brace when i play, but i've been able to keep up with everyone else and i feel very strong. I would highly reccomend getting it taken from your own hamstring. its a very hard recovery but if you work out alot and strengthen your knee, you will feel very strong with the end result.

good luck.
More Questions & Answers...
  • I have been coughing for over a week its a dry cough what in the world is it?
  • Compulsive eating disorder!?! help?
  • Can a gynecologist tell your parents any of your results or info if your 14 in FL?
  • Sleeping all day - still groggy and want to sleep, why?
  • Its it safe to keep a Dog with ring worm among others?
  • How large will a scar from a liver resection be?
  • How many days can i work for without a day off?
  • Rescheduling sleep patterns?
  • My mate at work is sixty one should he be valeting cars when he has £90000.00 in the bank?
  • The consumer health information on youqa.com is for informational purposes only and is not a substitute for medical advice or treatment for any medical conditions.
    The answer content post by the user, if contains the copyright content please contact us, we will immediately remove it.
    Copyright © 2007 YouQA.com -   Terms of Use -   Contact us

    Health Resources